History
The pre-1933 US $10 Eagle contains 0.48375 troy oz (15.047 g) of fine gold in a 16.718 g, 900 alloy coin. Liberty Head and Indian Head types were recalled from circulation in 1933, so many surviving pieces came back from European bank vaults. Worn common dates sell close to melt; better dates carry collector premiums.
Liberty Head eagle (1838–1907)
The Liberty Head or Coronet $10, designed by Christian Gobrecht, was struck from 1838 to 1907. Coins dated from 1866 carry IN GOD WE TRUST on a scroll above the eagle. Large numbers of 1880s–1900s Philadelphia and San Francisco coins survive, many repatriated from European banks, so these common dates trade at a modest premium over melt. Carson City (CC) and early New Orleans (O) coins are much scarcer.
Indian Head eagle (1907–1933)
Augustus Saint-Gaudens designed the Indian Head eagle, showing Liberty wearing a feathered headdress, with a standing eagle on the reverse. The first 1907–1908 coins omit IN GOD WE TRUST, which was added by Congress in 1908. The 1933 issue is a great rarity because nearly the whole mintage was melted. Common dates such as 1926 and 1932 are the most affordable and trade a little above melt.
Melt value versus collector value
The live calculator shows the melt value, the floor price for any genuine $10 eagle. Dealers usually pay a premium over that for common dates in decent condition, and far more for scarce dates, mintmarks and high grades. Keep coins in their original condition, do not clean them, and compare a coin dealer's offer with the melt value before selling.
Related: How much is a golden quarter worth? · Gold coin prices today